Defined Benefit (Pension) · DOL Form 5500 · 2023

Motorists Mutual Insurance Company Pension Plan

Data updated 2026-08-25

$71M
Total assets Below avg plan size
228
Participants Below avg headcount
89th
Percentile by assets National rank
$312,645
Avg per participant High balance/head
PlainRetire home → About this data RSS: change history

Official DOL plan name: Motorists Mutual Retirement Plan · Sponsored by Motorists Mutual Insurance Company · Ohio · Finance & Insurance

$71M in assets, 228 participants

Motorists Mutual Insurance Company's Motorists Mutual Retirement Plan reported $71M in total assets and 228 participants in its 2023 DOL Form 5500 filing, ranking in the 89th percentile by assets among filed plans. Figures are as reported by the plan sponsor to the Department of Labor, not audited or endorsed by PlainRetire.

  • #7,327 in Finance & Insurance (8,869 peers)

Coverage in Ohio

Motorists Mutual Retirement Plan covers 228 participants in Ohio, about 30% of the average Ohio filer (state average ~765 per filing). Assets: $71M.

#7,327
in Finance & Insurance (8,869 peers)
+5.4%
assets growth YoY
0.7×
vs typical plan assets (national mean)

Motorists Mutual Retirement Plan's outsized position by total assets

Motorists Mutual Retirement Plan vs every filed plan by assets

End-of-year total assets · plan year 2023 · DOL Form 5500

$71,283,022 Top 11% higher than 89% of 127,068 filed plans

This plan $0 $2,050,000,000 every filed plan with reported assets, bucketed by value

Dashed line + filled bar = this entry, among filed plans.

Source U.S. Department of Labor Form 5500 filings (EBSA) · plan year 2023

Motorists Mutual Retirement Plan among mid-size filed plans by headcount

Plan-year 2023 Form 5500 filings with a reported participant count, partitioned by headcount band, not by assets. Motorists Mutual Retirement Plan sits mid-pack in the medium band (228 participants).

What changed between DOL Form 5500 filings

plan year 2022 → plan year 2023

  • Motorists Mutual Retirement Plan reported net income rose from -$24M in the plan year 2022 filing to $4M in the plan year 2023 filing.
  • Motorists Mutual Retirement Plan reported participants fell from 250 in the plan year 2022 filing to 228 in the plan year 2023 filing.
  • Motorists Mutual Retirement Plan end-of-year assets rose from $68M in the plan year 2022 filing to $71M in the plan year 2023 filing.

See the national 2022→2023 release diff →

Plan-year Form 5500 strip

Filing strip 314259550 · Motorists Mutual Insurance Company PY 2023 · Defined Benefit (Pension)

Motorists Mutual Retirement Plan · $71M · 228 · 89th

  • BOY $71M
  • SCH 228
  • EBSA 89th
  • PART Defined Benefit (Pension)
  • TYPE near Sherwin Alumina Company Pension Plan for Hourly Employees
  • NET ind #7327

Stamps derive from this plan's Form 5500 line items (assets, participants, type, EIN, cohort placement) - not a quality rating of the sponsor. Read with Finance & Insurance retirement plans → · Plans in Ohio →

Motorists Mutual Retirement Plan in the asset neighbourhood

Roofers Local No. 74/ No. 203 Pension PlanRoofers Local No. 74/ No. 20…$71MSherwin Alumina Company Pension Plan for Hourly EmployeesSherwin Alumina Company Pens…$71MMotorists Mutual Retirement PlanMotorists Mutual Retirement …$71MRetirement Plan for Employees of Emerson HospitalRetirement Plan for Employee…$71MCabell Huntington Hospital, Inc. Union Employees' Retirement PlanCabell Huntington Hospital, …$71M
End-of-year total assets ($M) among Motorists Mutual Retirement Plan and nearest nationwide Defined Benefit (Pension) peers. Source: DOL Form 5500 plan year 2023.

Ohio filing particulars

Total Assets (Beginning of Year)$68M
Net Assets (End of Year)$71M
Net Income$4M
Employer EIN314259550
Plan Effective Date1945-12-14
Filing StatusFILING RECEIVED

Sponsor Plan History (Motorists Mutual Insurance Company)

Sponsor-wide plan assets over time

All Motorists Mutual Insurance Company plans reported in each filing year

Latest sponsor-wide plan assets
$419M 29.441508536667747% vs 2022
2024 filing year
$300M$350M$400M$450M 202220232024 $324M $419M ▲ +29.4%
Year Plans Participants Total Assets
2022 2 1,395 $324M
2023 2 1,388 $378M
2024 2 1,339 $419M

Nearby Defined Benefit (Pension) Plans in Ohio

Peer Defined Benefit (Pension) plans, same state, same plan type, ranked by total assets.

Motorists Mutual Retirement Plan vs. nearby Defined Benefit (Pension) plans in Ohio, assets vs. participants Scatter plot of 6 data points. -50000500010000150002000025000 -202468 Total assets ($B) Participants Motorists Mutual Retirement Plan, Total assets ($B): 0.071283022 · Participants: 228Motorists Mutual Retirement PlanFirstenergy Corp. Master Pension Plan, Total assets ($B): 7.144086795 · Participants: 12304Firstenergy Corp. Master Pension PlanNationwide Retirement Plan, Total assets ($B): 5.281060445 · Participants: 22311Nationwide Retirement PlanAmerican Electric Power System Retirement Plan, Total assets ($B): 4.475896468 · Participants: 15595American Electric Power System Retirement PlanParker Defined Benefit Plan, Total assets ($B): 3.656915014 · Participants: 191Parker Defined Benefit PlanOhio Operating Engineers Pension Plan, Total assets ($B): 3.592540979 · Participants: 10029Ohio Operating Engineers Pension Plan
Motorists Mutual Retirement Plan vs. nearby Defined Benefit (Pension) plans in Ohio, assets vs. participants
Compare Motorists Mutual Retirement Plan side-by-side with 3 peers →

Motorists Mutual Retirement Plan's out-of-state Defined Benefit (Pension) peers by assets and headcount

Outside Ohio, the nearest Defined Benefit (Pension) by assets is Sherwin Alumina Company Pension Plan for Hourly Employees in NY ($71M); by covered participants it is Meharry Medical College Retirement Income Plan in TN (228 participants). Same-state nearby plans are listed separately above.

Similar participant headcount

Nearest other-state filings by covered participants (228 participants); asset peers above are excluded.

DOL Form 5500 plan year 2023. Asset totals can differ widely at the same headcount; neither axis is a quality rating.

Frequently Asked Questions

How did Motorists Mutual Retirement Plan assets move in 2023? ▼
Motorists Mutual Retirement Plan grew at a solid clip - up 5.4% during 2023, from $68M to $71M. Reported net income was $4M.
How have Motorists Mutual Insurance Company plan assets changed over time? ▼
Across 3 plan years on file (2022-2024), Motorists Mutual Insurance Company's sponsor-wide assets grew 29.4%, from $324M to $419M.
Where does Motorists Mutual Retirement Plan rank by assets among Form 5500 filers? ▼
Motorists Mutual Retirement Plan ranks in the 89th percentile by end-of-year assets among 127,072 plans that reported assets for plan year 2023 (in the top quartile of all filed plans by assets).
Which Defined Benefit (Pension) plans are similar in size to Motorists Mutual Retirement Plan? ▼
Among Defined Benefit (Pension) plans in other states, the closest by assets is Sherwin Alumina Company Pension Plan for Hourly Employees in NY ($71M, N/A participants).
Which Defined Benefit (Pension) plans cover a similar participant headcount to Motorists Mutual Retirement Plan? ▼
Among Defined Benefit (Pension) plans in other states, the closest by covered participants is Meharry Medical College Retirement Income Plan in TN (228 participants, $5M in assets).

Source: U.S. Department of Labor, Employee Benefits Security Administration (EBSA), Form 5500 public disclosure dataset. Plan year 2023.

Source: DOL EFAST2 filing system (efast.dol.gov) - original filing retrieval by EIN 314259550.

Read our methodology - how this data is sourced, computed, and verified.

Data sourced from U.S. Department of Labor Form 5500 filings (EBSA). See our methodology for details.