Retirement Income Plan of Utica Mutual Insurance Company

Defined Benefit (Pension) · DOL Form 5500 · 2024

What the Filing Says About Retirement Income Plan of Utica Mutual Insurance Company

Retirement Income Plan of Utica Mutual Insurance Company is a Defined Benefit (Pension) retirement plan sponsored by Utica Mutual Insurance Company, headquartered in New York. According to the U.S. Department of Labor's 2024 Form 5500 filing, the plan reports $375M in total end-of-year assets and covers 240 participants across the Finance & Insurance industry. The sponsor's EIN on file with the U.S. Department of Labor is 150476880, and the plan has been effective since 1929-07-01. Its filing status is currently FILING RECEIVED.

Year over year, total assets edged up modestly from $367M at the beginning of 2024 to $375M at year-end - up 2.2%. Net assets (after liabilities) closed the year at $375M, with reported net income of $8M driven by investment returns, contributions received, and benefit payments during the period. These figures reflect what the plan administrator certified on Schedule H or Schedule I of the Form 5500 annual return and can be compared against 2 prior plan-year filings from the same sponsor shown below.

Across the 3 plan years Utica Mutual Insurance Company has on file with PlainRetire (2022-2024), sponsor-wide plan assets have moved from $608M to $723M, a gain of 18.8%, while reported participants moved from 1,608 to 1,647 (+2.4%). The strongest year on file by total sponsor assets was 2024 at $723M; the softest was 2022 at $608M. Year-by-year, sponsor-wide filings show: 2022 - $608M in assets across 2 plans covering 1,608 participants; 2023 - $688M in assets across 2 plans covering 1,604 participants; 2024 - $723M in assets across 2 plans covering 1,647 participants.

By assets, Retirement Income Plan of Utica Mutual Insurance Company outranks 96% of the 116,472 plans that filed a Form 5500 for the 2024 plan year, and holds roughly 3.8x the national average plan size of $100M and 730 average participants.

Asset totals and participant counts reflect a single plan year snapshot and can change materially with market conditions, plan mergers, or workforce changes. Fields such as "net income" include both realized investment performance and contribution/distribution flows, a single-year figure does not by itself indicate plan health or participant outcomes. This page summarizes public DOL disclosures for research and educational purposes only and is not retirement, tax, legal, or financial advice. Before making decisions about your own retirement benefits or evaluating an employer's plan, verify the underlying filing directly via the DOL EFAST2 system and consult a qualified professional.

How the percentile is calculated: we count every plan that filed a 2024 Form 5500 with a reported end-of-year asset figure (116,472 plans), rank Retirement Income Plan of Utica Mutual Insurance Company against all of them by total assets, and report the share of those plans it outranks. A plan reporting no asset figure for the year is excluded from the ranking rather than assumed to be zero.